It's nearly impossible to wrap my brain around the tragic events that unfolded at a Century movie theatre in Aurora, Colorado.
By now, we all know that a mad man (whose name I refuse to type because I don't want to give him more notoriety) stood before a crowd that had gathered to watch the midnight screening of the film The Dark Knight Rises.
Dressed in full riot gear, the assassin allegedly tossed tear gas canisters onto the floor, then mercilessly opened fire on the crowd. In the end, 12 people were killed and 59 were injured.
As stories of the massacre hit the media, I have to admit that I was surprised to discover just how many children were in the theatre that terrifying night. The tragedy started several debates, such as the need for stricter gun control, but many people have been questioning why children were at a midnight screening of a PG-13 movie in the first place.
Reports have named a baby as young as 3-months-old as being one of the injured. A six-year-old girl named Veronica Moser-Sullivan was among the victims who lost their lives that night. A young family barely escaped with their lives.
Jamie Rohrs, and his fiancee, Patricia Legarreta, attended the screeing with their four-month-old son and four-year-old daughter. In an interview with ABC news, Rohrs said the two took their children to the show because they figured they'd sleep through it.
"We just moved here from New Mexico," he said. "We have to go out. We have to do things. You don't think you're going to get shot. You're just living your life."
I'm not claiming to be an expert on parenting, but I would not take my children to see a PG-13 film. Of course, I have two very sensitive boys who get nervous just walking into a dark movie theatre. Not to mention that if I attempted to take my 3-year-old to a movie that started as late as midnight, his exhausted fussing would be louder than the film itself.
That being said, I don't fail to see the parallels between the real life atrocities witnessed at the screening and the violent images presented in The Dark Knight Rises. The villain, Bane, sets a reign of terror on Gotham City and goes so far as to blow up a football stadium, killing innocent football players.
I believe that we would have a better chance at raising peaceful adults if children were not exposed to extreme media violence early in their lives. It makes me sick to think that innocent children were killed, injured, or even that they saw such terror.
I am not placing blame on the parents of the young victims or witnesses of the horrible incident. My heart goes on to every single person who was in the theatre that fateful night. After all, parents should be able to take their children wherever they choose without the fear of a mentally deranged person opening fire in front of them.
I know that lives were lost and that now is not the time to pass judgment. My hope is that as our nation heals from this nightmare, we can reflect on the changes that we can make as parents to promote peace in our world instead of violence.
Would you take your children to see a midnight screening of a PG-13 movie? Do you think that movie violence can influence children? Please share your thoughts and experiences in the comments.
Rebecca McCarthy
6:15 am on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Leigh, this was my first thought when I heard a six-year-old had been killed. Who in their right mind would take a little child to something so scary and violent? I remember being in the theater for "Witches," a Roald Dahl-based movie about, well, witches who ate children. Good for adults. But not for the little boy who literally screamed the house down--they had to stop the movie and tell his mother to take him out. She was just going to let him scream. I know people want to "go out and have fun," but when you have infants and little children, you find other ways to have fun without subjecting them to violence and violent noise. At least, I hope so.Heck, the flying monkeys in the Wizard of Oz still scare me.....
Leigh Hewett
1:23 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
My children would be WAY too terrified to even sit through the previews.
Becky
9:07 am on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
I think being scared is a thrill that people naturally seek out - look at roller coasters. But normal people seek it in safe environments, movie theatres, theme parks, etc. I'm torn between the desire to have a more peaceful society and the amount I enjoy the Batman movies.
I can think of many reasons I would not have taken my young daughter and son to the theater that night, but it wasn't my choice. A movie theater is usually and should be a safe place for everyone, as should a mall (I don't take my kids there much either) or any other public place. Who knows why the mom did it. Maybe she was at a point of really needing to get out, maybe the sitter cancelled at the last minute. We've all made selfish parenting decisions at one time or another. Nobody could reasonably have been prepared for that, though sneaking in the back exit has long been a theater trick and one I would think they could have solved by now.
Leigh Hewett
9:53 am on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
This was a hard article to write but I think that it's a topic worth discussing. My heart hurts for the Veronica's mother and if she were in front of me, I would give her a big hug and cry with her. What's done is done and only the shooter is to blame. I'm not about blaming the victims. I was hoping to start a respectful discussion about the choices YOU make as a parent. Not to pass judgement on the parents of the victims.
disgruntled
10:41 am on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
It doesn't matter why a parent took their child to see the movie. This wouldn't be a discussion at all had that man not come in and shot them. As you stated in the article parents thought their children would sleep thru it. Had I not had to work that night(for a police dept) I would have taken my 6 and 10 year olds to the midnight showing. It is something special and different to be able to stay up that late for them and it's not like they had school the next day. We as a society don't need to hibernate with our children inside our homes because of the crazies out there. Our children should be able to watch any kind of movie there is and as a parent it is our duty to teach them the difference in right and wrong.
Rebecca McCarthy
10:48 am on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
This is a topic Leigh has long been interested in: movie ratings and showing little children media that's meant for older children. You think that one should be able to watch any kind of movie. I guess the question would be, at what age? I guess that depends on the children and what they have been exposed to beforehand. My girls still have a hard time with Peter Rabbit's dad getting eaten by the McGregor's, so I doubt they would be ready for "The Dark Knight Rises." You are so right that we don't need to hibernate because of nuts running around with guns---as parents we weigh risks and benefits and go forward. You know, I think the problem with normal people vs. nuts is that normal people would never imagine someone doing something like the shooter is alleged to have done, or like the World Trade Center nuts did. We just can't imagine something like that happening....but it does, and unfortunately, it will.
Jesse
12:27 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
I'm sure that Leigh's regular readers would argue that this topic is very much something she would have covered in spite of the tragedy. We're all emotional and sad about what happened but I think that discussing children's exposure to media violence is appropriate. I wish that it was under less traumatic circumstances though.
Linda Labbo
10:45 am on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
I have viewed PG 13 movies with my children because I had done research or pre-viewed and knew we could discuss any "sensitive" situations; however, I personally wouldn't take young children to a midnight movie. My sister-in-law, an educator of deaf children, also told me that the decible levels in that type of movie do damage to infant/toddler's hearing within 5 minutes! Like you, my heart goes out to everyone in that theater and those surrounding. May justice be done.
Linda Jakab
1:59 am on Friday, July 27, 2012
Your first thoughts were mine too Linda. My kids are currently wearing out the DVD of Harry Potter 3, but we read the book together first and my partner and I have both seen the film. I wouldn't let my kids watch a PG movie without my preview because the rating doesn't reflect enough detail. For example, a local TV station recently played "Coraline" in the family 6.30 time slot. I love that movie but there is no way I am subjecting my 4 and 7 year old to that mind twisting plot.
Jesse
12:18 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
It took some guts to publish this article so soon after the tragedy. I would not take my kids to a PG-13 film or even a midnight screening. My kids would be scared and miserable. Every kid is different, though. The fact that this maniac did what he did is unthinkable. I don't think that early exposure to a super hero movie is the problem though, I think that the fact that he had such easy access to the weapons and ammunition is the big problem. The best we can do as parents is not let this whack job change how we live our lives. We take our kids where we want and be vigilant. I think that you handled this topic very sensitively and have given us all something to think about. So sad, so terribly sad.
Rebecca McCarthy
12:24 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Thanks for your thoughtful comments, Jesse.
Leigh Hewett
1:26 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
I agree. The best revenge is to survive and thrive. Thanks for commenting, Jesse. You always leave such great comments.
Carolyn Gravit
12:25 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
I live in Aurora, Co. I have faith that the community will heal but it will be a long painful journey. My heart too aches most for Veronica, her own mother is in the hospital with a gunshot would to her neck. She didn't know about her daughters passing until recently. Painful. My grandmother told me the year my mom passed "there is nothing worse than burying your child" and Lord knows I believe it. It is easy for us to forget that children & families are all different. Economically, physically and emotionally different. There is no way for us to know each of these families circumstances. Are they the biggest Batman fans ever? Did they lose a babysitter at the last minute? is there six year old prepared for PG-13. The nightly news can be more severe than PG-13 movies. School is out for most but the long gone innocence of summer no longer exists, especially in Aurora. Thanks for posting, Leigh.
Rebecca McCarthy
12:39 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Carolyn,
Everyone around the country is so sad for your community. One of my closest friends lived in the "Dam East" and we visited her there. I thought it was a great place for families to kick back, ride bikes and go to school. I'm sure it still is. Your comment about the innocence of summer being gone is heartbreakingly true. Thanks for posting.
Leigh Hewett
1:42 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Carolyn,
I'm so sorry that your community is faced with this. I have family in Aurora and my brother works at Children's Hospital, so this tragedy hit close to home all the way in Georgia. I really like what you have to say about families being different. We don't know what it's like to walk in someone else's shoes or what their circumstances are. Once again, my heart aches that you and those around you are having to deal with this nightmare.
Becky
12:47 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
I didn't mean to be accusatory. As I read I just kept thinking about how many times in my own parenting life that having time frozen and being thrown into a spotlight of any kind, much less a national one would have been disastrous.
Back on your topic, I let my daughter see a lot of movies not really suitable for her age (Lord of the Rings Trilogy) but have withheld many she wanted to watch (Alien) because of the type of violence or sex that is portrayed. She is very good at telling fantasy from fact and always has been, having been an avid reader since she found her first book. My son is a whole 'nother matter and I keep violence of all kinds from him as much as possible because he imitates everything he sees and has no ability to distinguish fantasy and reality. He also is prone to nightmares, which my daughter never was. We watch Kipper and Bob the Builder and don't even watch the old Batman TV show or Spiderman.
On another media topic, I have banned all tween shows (Hannah M, I Carley, etc.) from our house because of the way my daughter behaves and interacts after watching them. They cause far more issues than well-written mature films!
Rebecca McCarthy
12:55 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Becky, I can tell when my girls have watched commercial television at a friend's house because they start saying, "Oh, yeah?" and "You can't tell me what to do." At home, they watch only videos they pick and we vet, but at other people's houses, it seems that anything goes. The messages of those tween shows are not ones I want in my house. And, while we're on it, how 'bout the slutty clothes? Those amaze and somewhat distress me....
Leigh Hewett
1:25 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Becky,
I didn't think that anything you said was accusatory. I agree that no parent is perfect and I know that Veronica's mom will regret her decision for the rest of her life. My heart goes out to her. It's like the unthinkable happened.
Scarlet Buckley
12:48 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
I absolutely agree that exposing our kids to violent movies, t.v. computer games, etc. effect the brain, and I am really concerned about the amount of violence that little kids are regularly exposed to through cartoons and video games. We have a cultural problem of violent media.
Erin Lashley
12:59 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
No, she shouldn't have been there, more because of the hour than the content, but that still doesn't mean it serves her surviving family members right that she is dead. I have been reading comments along those lines since I got up Friday morning, and all I can say is that I hope people who are are so callous are just dealing with tragedy by appearing to harden their hearts. I'm sure if the child had been at Gymboree on a Tuesday at 9 AM while eating organically grown fruit, and the Gymboree had been shot up, it would be a chorus condemning privileged yuppie breeders and their recreational activities. Some people are just going to tear other people down to make themselves feel better, and God bless 'em, that's just the way they are.
Rebecca McCarthy
1:05 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
It certainly doesn't "serve her right" because it's not the fault of the mom or anyone else who was there that a nutjob went into a public place and killed people. What about the people going about their jobs in the World Trade Center? Or the students calmly reading in the Columbine library? Or the woman enjoying Centennial Park during the 1996 Atlanta Olympics? None of these people was doing anything that would appear to be life-threatening. In each case, twisted minds and empty hearts killed them. It can happen anywhere, and it does, and it will.
Erin Lashley
1:28 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Did you understand that I said it doesn't mean it serves them right, but that I have been reading comments that said it did, and I was condemning those comments?
Leigh Hewett
2:03 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Love your Gymboree comment. Sad but true, I believe.
Leigh Hewett
1:21 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
I just read this chilling essay written by Dylan Klebold's (one of the Columbine shooters) mom. It's a heartbreaking read but shows how crucial it is that we stay aware of what our children (but mostly teenagers) carry in their minds.
http://www.oprah.com/world/Susan-Klebolds-O-Magazine-Essay-I-Will-Never-Know-Why/
Becky
1:59 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Wow.
Rebecca McCarthy
3:30 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Erin, I did understand that. : )
Athens Mama
3:59 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
I think the issues of kids watching PG-13 movies and seeing Batman are complicated. Different kids have different levels of sensitivity. As far as rating, I find it to be more of a problem when kids are routinely exposed to mature content, and particularly when they are exposed to mature content without an adult guide there to stimulate conversation about the content. I will say that I don't think that having kids out late is a bad thing. Some families life on different schedules and it is an adventure to go out to a friend's late or to do something creative late at night. I also think the lack of a babysitter often influences what kids do with their parents. Such sadness for so many lives senselessly lost.
Himmat Guron
10:30 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Leigh Hewett,
You ask a very thoughtful and academic question, "would you take your children to a midnight........etc"
However the context and timing of your questions shed much light on your frigid heart portraying an utter disregard to the mother who has to live with the loss of her child. Is it not bad enough that the mother is having to cope with the loss of her daughter without you adding further pain by asking such questions. Questions of this nature are left to a classroom or behind closed doors where the actors are not made aware that they are the subjects of a psuedo intellectual discourse. Leigh, if you have an iota of humanity, you need to work on removing this article from the web and save it for a private discussion where the the grieving mother or relatives do not have access and therefore will not have to contend with another aspect in their healing.
In closing I have to ask that you put yourself in the others shoes before you embark on another intellectual discourse because this is a very poor chosen portrayal of your intellect.
Best regards sincerely,
Himmat "HS"
Rebecca McCarthy
10:37 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Thanks for your comments.
Leigh Hewett
7:34 am on Thursday, July 26, 2012
Himmat,
I understand your perspective but if you knew me in real life you would know that I actually have a very compassionate heart. The last thing that I want to do is cause more heartache for a grieving mother and I actually spent a good amount of time meditating on this article, to write it with integrity and I stand by what I've said here. I think that it's natural to reflect on your own life after a tragedy like this happens. To ponder how easily it could have been you or your child in that position. To think about what you may do the same or different as the victims. I also think that it's important to talk about uncomfortable topics, if it can bring healing and change. I hope that you can see the difference between bashing that poor mother and trying to open a respectful dialogue. I'm sorry that you see this in a negative light and hope that we can all find healing in the wake of this terrible event. Thank you for taking the time to read and comment.
Linda Labbo
9:31 am on Friday, July 27, 2012
Just another thought. I was in Colorado when the shooting happened. Some of my family and friends lost loved ones or had a friend injured by the shooting. I join them in grieving deeply, and I know Leigh does as well. There were such acts of heroism and the best that humanity has to offer during this terrible tragedy. The outcome of such tragedy is to grieve with the victims, but to also take a few moments to reflect on your own life. Leigh invited readers to join her in wondering if they would take children to a midnight show. For me, I think about being in that dark chaos and finding the courage to help fallen friends and strangers. There were many heroes to be hailed in this awful situation. I know Leigh honors them, too.
Sue Anderson
3:58 pm on Tuesday, July 31, 2012
I would take a new baby, yes, because he or she would be sleeping. And if the baby was not a reliable sleeper at midnight, I would leave him/her home.
I would not take a child who would be awake. No way. Nohow. Because I totally think movie violence affects children.