My morning coffee in the garden was not the usual pleasant little stroll around the yard. Those darn deer have eaten the tops of Eva's magenta impatiens, although they didn't touch my white impatiens.
As I was checking my newly planted chartreuse hosta, I found they dined on one particular variety. Also, the blue hosta flowers had started blooming and now they have been chomped down.
Plus, they ate the girls' Sweet 100 cherry tomatoes. The picky little devils just ate the ripe ones. Yep, I know for sure it was deer because they left several "deposits" in my garden beds.
Around 6:30 am last Saturday morning, I saw a doe in my front yard and yelled "GO AWAY" but she just looked at me. So then I started banging on my upstairs bedroom window, and this finally made her leave.
All of this was AFTER she had feasted on Annabelle hydrangeas for breakfast. All of the blooms and quite a few leaves were gone when I got downstairs. For some unknown reason, she didn't touch the blue mopheads, just my beloved Annabelles.
Please take a gander at my before and after photos. I would say the deer are endangering my property. Now the question: how do I get rid of the deer?
For the past two weeks this frustrated gardener has researched the internet, DNR, local ordinances. and has questioned gardeners on how to banish deer. I read that the most effective deer repellents target a deer's keen sense of taste and smell.
You can find recipes online for homemade deer repellent. Most of them have rotten eggs, garlic, and some type of hot pepper. Most directions tell you to spray it on your plants. Supposedly, deer think this stench is a decaying animal and perceive predators to be nearby, creating a fear for the deer.
So Saturday afternoon Eva, 7, and I decided to make our own concoction of deer repellent which she named "Deer Away." You can see her handwritten recipe in the photos. We decided not to spray it on the tomatoes, but rather made five separate bowls of our nasty concoction and placed them in strategic places in my yard.
I think we made one major mistake...the eggs were not rotten. The next day it looked like Randy, the neighborhood raccoon, ate all the eggs and proceeded to drop the egg shells (which we had left in the bowls) all over the yard.
Please allow me to share with you some suggestions from fellow gardeners which I am trying:
Sandy Sanders from Charlotte, NC, emailed: "Try the mountain remedy for deer that my plumber told me about....Irish Spring soap bars. He drills a hole in each bar, places a string or rope through the hole and hangs it near what the bastards are eating. He swears it works."
I am trying Irish Spring as you can see in the photo of my pear tree. I have not been able to harvest pears for the last 3 years because the deer have eaten all of them. One day I will have a tree full of pears and literally overnight they will all be gone. If it works, I will ship Mr. Sanders a jar of homemade pear preserves.
Eva also had a solution for the pear tree. She suggested that we pick all the pears and take them down to the street so the deer will stay out of my yard.
Howard Cordell from Dublin, GA, emailed regarding our homemade deer repellent: "If it doesn't work as desired-- go to a garden store and buy some bags of Milorganite. Sprinkle all around area desired. It works for us." Okay, I went to Cofer's and purchased Milorganite and spread around my hosta. We shall see.
Claude Bolton, who lives in East Athens said his neighbor uses monofilament fishing line. He stretches it around his garden. I might try this where the deer jump over my fence. Did you know a deer can jump 12 feet high from a standing position?
Janie Bush, next door, uses "Deer Off." But that hasn't kept the deer out of her yard. Tuesday morning, they ate all her butterscotch lilies.
Peter Ray suggested using blood meal and dial soap. He throws those leftover tiny slivers of soap in his beautiful gardens at Belmont Farm. I put blood meal around my veggie garden this afternoon. I have tried human hair clippings from the beauty salon, but when it rains it washes the scent away.
Stuart Cofer of Cofer's Home and Garden suggest Liquid Fence and said it worked at his house.
Terr Kay's advice was: "As to your question about the deer, here's the only sure remedy. Break an egg and beat it well, then mix it well with three or four cups of water. Put it in a spray bottle and spray your plants. Deer won't touch them...unless it rains and washes the egg mix off. When that happens, you re-mix and re-spray."
If any of you have solutions on getting these greedy gluttons away from our plants, please share it in the comments. I will try anything that is legal.
Speaking of legal, advice I received from 2 hunters was "a 22 or a 30 ought 6 would do the job." I am very well aware one cannot shoot a gun in the middle of a Five Points neighborhood. But, I do have Daddy's old bows and arrows tucked away in an upstairs bedroom. Maybe it's time for archery lessons.
One last tip and probably the best: I had the pleasure of meeting Oconee County resident Richard White the other day and found out he is a wildlife removal specialist. Squirrels, snakes, or anything that invades your home or land. He has been known to remove a dead deer that was impaled on a tall fence.
Richard tells me one of the most successful methods is archery. Archery deer hunting season starts in September, but I wonder if I will have any plants left by then? I have jotted down his phone number in my address book...706.202.6696.
For those who read Bambi and don't want to kill these four-legged munchers, will you please sign them up for Debra Lassiter's Perfectly Polished etiquette school? They need to learn some respect for the hard work and love which gardeners put into their plants.
Nancy Zechella
11:11 am on Sunday, June 26, 2011
While harvesting tomatoes this morning, Eva accidently stepped in one of her bowls... YUCK all over her foot!
But she, Caroline and Molly found 7 ripe Rutgers and a dozen ripe cherry tomatoes. What a great garden crew... at work while I am sitting outside drinking my morning coffee.
Happy Birthday Caroline... Five years old today. By the way, Homeplace (at Five Points) has great garden equipment for little ones.
jessie greene
11:39 am on Sunday, June 26, 2011
I am collecting dog hair for my neighbor and I to gross out the small herd we have in our neighborhood.
Keep up the fun messages, Nancy
All the best
Jessie Greene
Nancy Zechella
12:03 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
Hey Jessie, Thanks for that tip, I had never thought of dog hair...that is worth a trip to a local dog-groomer's salon. I wonder if keeping a dog outside would keep away the deer?
Maggie Tretter
1:23 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
I've had good luck by planting wormwood/mugwort outside of the yard. Nothing smells good enough to jump the fence for. But, when I didn't have a fence, I used the garlic, hot peppers, eggs spray. Use habeneros, don't mess around with the namby-pamby jalepenos. :)
Nancy Zechella
2:11 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
Thank you Maggie. I didn't even know what mugwort and wormwood were.. So did a little googling. Looks like I need to start growing herbs. Here are some suggestions of herbs that repell deer:
"Fortunately for the herbalist, most of our favorite plants are naturally deer-proof. The essential oils generated by rosemary and lavender we adore are repulsive to deer. Many culinary plants have these strong odors, and it's easy to encourage them to intensify their scents by decreasing their watering schedule. When these herbs are drought-stressed, they protect themselves by producing more deer-repellant essential oils. A few dear-repellant plants to consider are:"
Thyme
Rosemary
Lavender
Sage
Artemisia - ie. Mugwort, Wormwood
Mints - ie. Lemon Balm, Spearmint
Walnut
Dill
Hyssop
Alliums - ie. Garlic, Chives
Elderberry
Rue
Yarrow
Nasturtium
Feverfew
http://www.thepracticalherbalist.com/component/content/article/64-garden-how-to/215-deer-proofing-your-garden.html
Next week's visit to Cofer's will be buying herbs.
Camille Templeton
3:32 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
We have six-foot deer netting around our garden and our little dog barks her head off if she sees deer. We have had more problems with bunny rabbits this year, they squeeze under the net. I have heard of people using brightly colored fabric banners to deter garden pests.
Nancy Zechella
10:30 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
Camille, Thank you so much for your tips. I like the idea of brightly colored fabric banners. I could put those around different areas in my back yard. Good luck with the bunny rabbits.
Meg Dure
3:37 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
One of the bonuses that came with our house, Nancy, is the beautiful brick wall that surrounds the yard. It must be the reason I have no trouble with deer. But Roger Raccoon visits after visiting your yard...bungee cords have foiled the beast on my garbage cans! Now if I could only do something about the chipmunks. They are the worst. This is an excellent article!
Nancy Zechella
5:14 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
Did I tell you, I caught Roger/Randy sitting on my brick sidewalk outside the kitchen door one night. I made the mistake of putting a trash bag out there (didn't want to walk to the trash can in the dark). He didn't move when I turned the light on. I had to make some noise before he left...then I put the bag inside the house for the evening. He was a beautiful animal.
PS: I am so envious of your gorgeous pierced brick wall.
Jared Finkelstein
9:08 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
My company, Teich Garden Systems, designs and installs gardens that deter deer and burrowing animals. It will let you enjoy the fruits (and vegetables) of your labors and will look good too.
Nancy Zechella
7:09 am on Monday, June 27, 2011
Thank you Jared for commenting. I am curious, how did you hear about my column?
I noticed on your website that your company installs community, school and home gardens. I have already sent a friend in Arizona your company link to Senoir Gardening.
If anyone wants to persure the webiste, it is listed below.
http://www.teichgardensystems.com/
Jared Finkelstein
10:12 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
I saw a tweet with a link to your article. The power of twitter :)
Nancy Zechella
10:27 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
Thanks for letting me know.
If there are any educational folks reading this column, you might want to read the Wilton Patch article on Wilton High School's organic garden. Teich Garden Systems installed the garden for them. What a great idea :)
http://wilton.patch.com/articles/wilton-high-schools-organic-garden-flourishes
Jared Finkelstein
10:33 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
Thank you :) We have a couple of school/community gardens in the Atlanta area as well. if anyone wants to try to see our garden system first-hand we can try to get them the information.
Maggie Tretter
10:46 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
Just remember, artemsia plants will "sour" (for lack of a better word) the soil so other plants (especially veggies) won't grow as well. But, most herbs will help with companion planting. :) I know it's helping with the deer and those nasty little potato bugs.
Nancy Zechella
11:23 pm on Sunday, June 26, 2011
Maggie, Thank you. Your tips are always helpful...I am guessing you are a great gardener. Anytime you wish to download pix, please do so. It is very easy, just click on add photos located under my pix.
Steve Pettis
10:49 am on Monday, June 27, 2011
The only real control for deer is an 8' fence. I manage a research nursery professionally and can testify to the fact. Nothing else guarantees deer exclusion.
However, deer are creatures of habit. Deer are nervous creatures. These two characteristics can be exploited.
Deer travel the same paths day after day unless something along their path disturbs/scares them. Then they will adjust their daily movements to avoid the disturbance.
I try scare tactics in my own yard. When I notice a deer visiting my yard regularly I will scare it by making a loud noise. If you do this a couple of time the deer will avoid your home for a time. Their fear of your noisy yard has to supersede their hunger so persistence on your part is essential especially if your yard is a lush 'salad bowl'.
Repellents do work but are a great deal of work to maintain. If you were trying them now you would have to reapply each day as these evening thundershowers would wash them away. Milorganite (composted sewage) to my understanding is the best repellent since it soaks into the soil and the stinky human waste sewage plant smell stays around a while. It is also a great fertilizer.
Some companies make motion activated noise makers. Others make motion activated sprinklers to spray the critters when the walk by.
I have heard the monofilament fishing line can work. However it breaks down in sunlight and can be another plastic pollutant that is difficult to keep track of.
Nancy Zechella
11:32 am on Monday, June 27, 2011
Thank you Steve!
I have read that a fence should be at an angle, making it more difficult for the deer to jump over...is that true?
How much are motion activated noise makers and can you buy them locally? Sounds ike a good idea, but are they so loud they might wake up the little girls nextdoor...boy would I ever get in trouble for that!
Nancy Zechella
10:14 pm on Thursday, June 30, 2011
Reporting in: Yesterday afternoon I threw away Eva's nasty concoction of homemade Deer Away. Mainly, because the bowls were collecting rain water and I don't want any more mosquitoes.
There were approximately 3 dozen ripe tomatoes on the vines and they are all gone today. The deer left evidence of "deposits" and teeth marks in the green tomatoes they dropped on the ground. Guess they didn't like the green ones.
So far the Irish Spring soap and Milorganite are working in other parts of the yard. Forget the blood meal...that was near the tomatoes.
Nancy Zechella
12:29 pm on Saturday, July 9, 2011
I just paid the water bill for my gardens. I could have taken the darn deer to Five and Ten for dinner and gotten by with less money spent.
Jared Finkelstein
9:13 pm on Saturday, July 9, 2011
Our systems have built in irrigation systems which, with the use of landscape fabric, minimize water usage :) so lower water bills and deer kept at bay
Nancy Zechella
9:36 pm on Friday, September 9, 2011
They are everywhere!
Atlanta Journal reporting deer run into Publix grocery store.
http://www.ajc.com/news/gwinnett/oh-deer-fawn-go-1165796.html
Nancy Zechella
7:08 am on Monday, June 11, 2012
Update on deer, June 2012: nature has taken its course, we now have a coyote in the neighborhood. I saw him/her in my front yard about a week ago. No deer anywhere and the Annabelle hydrangeas, hosta, and my neighbor's butterscotch lilies are in full bloom!
Rebecca McCarthy
7:37 am on Monday, June 11, 2012
Sometimes predators can be helpful!